I was trying to be provocative. I understood what you mean, and I was disappointed by what you said, and you confirmed it in your answer.

We, humans, are mainly emotional, which means that whatever reasoning, emotions play a huge role in our decisions, whatever the rules and framework we use. Thus, I really doubt that you and your colleagues are like Spokc in Star Trek, without emotions.

Human judgement to be fair needs a lot of experience. That means subjectivity is real whover is at the maneuver.